How Much Does Landlord Insurance Cost?

The cost of landlord insurance varies widely based on location, property characteristics, tenant types, and chosen coverage levels. On average, landlords can expect to pay around $1,300 per year, but it’s crucial to obtain personalized quotes to understand specific costs for your property.

How much does landlord insurance cost? This article cuts through the complexity to provide you with an understanding of the factors that influence landlord insurance premiums. Expect insights on location, property type, tenant profiles, and an exploration of cost-saving strategies that could impact your bottom line.

Key Takeaways

  • Landlord insurance costs an average of $1,300 per year and is influenced by factors such as property location, type, value, and tenant demographics, potentially leading to significant premium variations.

  • Landlord insurance is comparatively more expensive than homeowners insurance due to the greater risk profile, increased liability concerns, and additional coverage features such as loss of rent.

  • Landlord insurance policies come in varying levels of protection, with DP-1 offering basic coverage for named perils at actual cash value, DP-2 providing broader coverage on a replacement cost basis, and DP-3 delivering comprehensive open peril coverage typically on a replacement cost basis.

Average Landlord Insurance Costs and Factors

The average cost of landlord insurance is approximately $1,300 per year. This translates to around $100 per month. However, this cost is not set in stone. Various factors can influence your landlord’s insurance premium, leading to potential fluctuations.

Factors that can affect your rental property insurance costs include:

  • Location: If your rental property is located in an area with a high crime rate or prone to natural disasters, you may pay higher premiums.

  • Type of rental property: The type of property you own, such as a single-family home or a multi-unit building, can impact your insurance costs.

  • Property value: The value of your rental property will also affect your insurance premiums.

  • Type of tenants: The type of tenants you accommodate, such as students or families, can cause variations in insurance costs.

For instance, premium properties or those considered higher risk may incur higher premiums, while long-term tenants on year-long leases may suggest stability, potentially leading to lower insurance premiums.

You can read more of our blogs about Landlord Insurance for more information.

DID YOU KNOW?  landlord insurance policies can offer coverage for lost rental income? This feature is particularly beneficial for landlords during periods when their property is uninhabitable due to covered damages, ensuring a continuous income stream even when facing unexpected events.

Comparing Homeowners and Landlord Insurance Costs

When it comes to homeowners insurance versus landlord insurance, it’s important to note that the latter generally costs 15%-20% more. Why the difference? The answer lies in:

  • the risk profile for rental properties

  • increased liability concerns

  • the fact that tenant-occupied properties tend to file more frequent and higher claims.

Moreover, landlord insurance offers additional coverages, such as loss of rent and landlord insurance coverage, which homeowners insurance does not provide, resulting in higher premiums for landlords. Landlord insurance policies are about 25% costlier than homeowners policies for the same property.

Types of Rental Property Coverage

Navigating through the different types of rental property coverage can be challenging. Let’s simplify. Landlord insurance policies can be divided into three main types: DP-1 (basic), DP-2 (upgraded), and DP-3 (comprehensive). Each type offers a varying degree of protection, designed to suit different needs and circumstances.

Let’s delve into each of these types to shed some light on the specifics.

Basic Coverage (DP-1)

Starting with the most basic, the DP-1 landlord insurance policy is designed for landlords seeking coverage for specifically named perils. The coverages under a DP-1 policy typically include:

  • Fire

  • Wind

  • Hail

  • Lightning

  • Aircraft

  • Internal and external explosions

  • Riots

  • Smoke

  • Vehicles

  • Volcanic explosions

  • Windstorms

One important thing to note is that the DP-1 policy pays out based on the actual cash value of damaged properties, factoring in depreciation to determine reimbursement amounts. If you have properties that remain vacant for a prolonged period, require only basic coverage, or are in between tenants, the DP-1 policy may be an advantageous option for you.

Upgraded Coverage (DP-2)

Taking a step up, the DP-2 policy provides an upgraded level of coverage. Unlike DP-1, it pays out on a replacement cost basis, covering the cost to repair or replace damaged property without accounting for depreciation. The DP-2 policy typically covers 17 named perils such as:

  • vandalism

  • explosions

  • fire

  • windstorm

  • hail

  • burglary damage

  • snow

  • ice damage

  • water damage

  • collapses

And others.

An added advantage of DP-2 is that it covers not only the primary structure but also connected structures like fences, sheds, or detached garages. However, it’s important to remember that the policy excludes coverage for theft, damage from improper maintenance, earthquakes, floods, and general water damage. If you rent out your properties primarily as a source of income or while awaiting a property’s sale, the DP-2 policy could be well-suited for you.

Comprehensive Coverage (DP-3)

The DP-3 landlord insurance policy, also known as Dwelling Fire Form 3, is the most comprehensive and expensive policy. Operated as an open peril policy, it covers all risks unless specifically excluded within the agreement and typically reimburses the landlord on a replacement cost basis.

Common exclusions in DP-3 policies can include ordinance or law changes, earth movement, power failure, war, neglect, nuclear hazard, governmental action, mold, and intentional loss.

Additional benefits of DP-3 coverage include:

  • Protection for the structure of the home

  • Fair rental value

  • Potential inclusion of personal liability coverage, securing the landlord if the property becomes uninhabitable, or if legal issues arise on the premises.

Ways to Save on Landlord Insurance Costs

While landlord insurance is a necessary expense, it doesn’t mean you can’t find ways to lower your costs. Here are some ways to reduce your landlord insurance premiums:

  • Property upgrades

  • Choosing higher deductibles

  • Bundling insurance policies

  • Regular property maintenance

  • Implementation of safety measures such as security cameras and efficient lighting

These measures can reduce the insurance risk profile and lead to lower premiums.

Upgrading key property systems like plumbing, heating, and electrical can yield better insurance terms upon policy renewal and help manage overall costs. Moreover, consolidating multiple properties under a single master policy and engaging in valuation discussions with insurance providers can streamline coverage and potentially lower premiums.

Calculating the Right Amount of Coverage

Determining the right amount of coverage is a crucial step in the landlord insurance process. To calculate appropriate coverage, landlords should evaluate possible discrepancies between tax assessments of property values and the actual costs required to rebuild, ensuring enough coverage to rebuild without basing the amount on the property’s market value.

Replacement cost value (RCV) coverage will provide funds reflecting the current cost to rebuild a home, which can be estimated by contacting local home construction companies or real estate representatives to determine up-to-date rebuilding costs and multiplying by the property’s square footage. On the other hand, Actual Cash Value (ACV) coverage pays out the replacement cost minus depreciation, often resulting in lower premiums but potentially insufficient funds to rebuild the property to its former condition after damage.

Also, landlords should opt for liability insurance coverage that reflects their financial situation and risk tolerance, with many choosing at least $1,000,000 in liability coverage.

Optional Add-On Coverages to Consider

To enhance your coverage, consider adding optional coverages to your landlord insurance policy. These may include:

  • Burglary coverage

  • Vandalism coverage

  • Building code upgrades coverage

  • Flood Insurance

Adding these optional coverages can provide you with additional protection and peace of mind.

Vandalism and burglary, not typically covered in standard landlord policies, can be added to reimburse landlords for damages caused by vandalism and pay for stolen property. Building code upgrade coverage can bridge the financial gap for landlords when repairs or rebuilds need to meet higher building codes than the current property standard. And if your rental property is in a high-risk area, separate flood insurance is crucial, as flooding is often excluded from standard policies.

Common Exclusions in Landlord Insurance Policies

While landlord insurance offers extensive protection, there are certain exclusions. Landlord insurance typically does not cover tenant’s personal belongings, specific natural disasters, and intentional damage by the property owner. It is essential to understand the specifics of your landlord insurance coverage to ensure you have the right protection in place.

For instance, landlord insurance commonly excludes certain natural disasters, notably flood damage, and will not cover the tenant’s personal property. Intentional damage caused by the property owner and normal wear and tear are generally excluded from coverage. The policy also does not cover the tenant’s personal vehicle and typically excludes malfunctions of in-unit appliances and equipment, such as kitchen appliances or HVAC systems.

State-by-State Comparison of Landlord Insurance Costs

The cost of landlord insurance can also vary significantly by state. The national average cost for landlord insurance in the United States is about $1,680 per year.

However, the most expensive states for landlord insurance include Delaware, Rhode Island, Louisiana, North Dakota, and Florida, with costs ranging from approximately $1722 to $2561 per year.

Conversely, states with the least expensive landlord insurance premiums include:

  • Iowa and Vermont at about $110 per year

  • Wyoming at around $101 per year

  • Mississippi, Oklahoma, Nevada, Kentucky, and Arizona with costs ranging from $739 to $845 per year

Tax Implications and Deductions for Landlord Insurance

Not only does landlord insurance protect your investment, but it also comes with tax benefits, such as making your landlord insurance tax deductible. According to IRS guidelines, landlord insurance premiums are considered a deductible rental expense. This means that they are classified as ordinary and necessary expenses for managing, conserving, and maintaining rental property.

To accurately report landlord insurance on tax forms, they should be included under the ‘Insurance’ section of Schedule E, which is part of Form 1040 or 1040-SR and is specifically used for reporting rental property income and expenses. As a result, the rental income reported on tax returns is reduced by deductible expenses such as landlord insurance, effectively lowering the taxable income generated from rental properties.

Given the complexity of tax laws and the potential for changes in legislation, landlords are recommended to seek advice from a tax professional and keep precise records of insurance premiums for claiming deductions.

Filing a Claim: What to Expect

If you ever need to file a claim, it’s important to know what to expect. Immediately after an incident, you should contact your insurance agent or broker for guidance and have your policy number, details about the damage, and a reliable contact number ready. Your insurance company will then guide you through the process.

Make sure to thoroughly document the damage, taking photos or videos and listing any injuries that may have occurred. Keep all damaged items for inspection. In the claims process, you should meet with an insurance adjuster, complete and return the necessary insurance claims forms, and ensure all documentation and evidence are organized and readily available.

The resolution of a claim can range from a few hours to much longer depending on its complexity.

The Importance of Renters Insurance for Tenants

While landlord insurance protects your property, it’s equally important for tenants to have renters insurance. Landlord insurance typically does not cover tenants’ personal property, and landlords often require tenants to have renters insurance to provide this protection.

Renters insurance covers personal property for tenants in the event of covered events such as fire, wind damage, and theft, which a DP-3 policy does not offer in-depth coverage for. Requiring renters insurance helps protect tenants from the financial burden of replacing personal property in the event of theft, loss, or damage. It also ensures coverage for their belongings.

Plus, by minimizing the likelihood of claims on the landlord’s policy, encouraging tenants to have renters insurance may prevent an increase in a landlord’s insurance premiums. Renters insurance also fosters a sense of mutual respect for the property, encouraging tenants to:

  • maintain the rental in good condition

  • report any damages or issues promptly

  • take responsibility for their personal belongings

  • be more cautious and mindful of potential risks

People Also Ask - How Much Does Landlord Insurance Cost

Landlords in North Carolina should require renters insurance that covers at least $300,000 in liability coverage. This ensures protection against tenant-caused damage or injuries within the property.

The average cost of landlord insurance in Texas varies but is generally around 25% higher than homeowners insurance. For precise figures, landlords should get quotes based on their property specifics.

In California, the cost of landlord insurance depends on the property's location, type, and other risk factors. On average, it can range from $800 to $3,000 annually.

In Florida, the average landlord insurance cost can be influenced by factors like hurricane risk and property value. Typically, the rates are higher compared to the national average.

The Final Verdict - How Much Does Landlord Insurance Cost

Navigating the costs of landlord insurance is crucial for property owners to ensure they are adequately protected without overspending. Understanding that the average national cost is around $1,300 annually is just the starting point. The actual cost for you will depend on various factors, including your property’s location, type, and the specifics of the coverage you choose. By being informed and strategically selecting the right insurance policy, you can secure financial peace of mind as a landlord.

If you’re looking to safeguard your investment with a comprehensive landlord insurance policy or have questions about optimizing your insurance costs, we encourage you to reach out to an ALLCHOICE Insurance Advisor. Our experts are on hand to provide personalized advice and solutions tailored to your unique needs as a property owner.

How to get Landlord Insurance

New ALLCHOICE customers:
Current ALLCHOICE clients:

Check out the Member Center or call us at 1-844-540-0463 to see if product is availbale and included in your policy.