CYBER INSURANCE EDUCATION — NORTH CAROLINA

What to Do If Ransomware Hits Your Small Business in NC

QUICK ANSWER

Disconnect infected computers first if ransomware hits your small business, then call your cyber insurer's breach hotline before paying or hiring new vendors. Preserve evidence, report the attack to the FBI, and don't pay a ransom without your insurer and an attorney. If personal information was taken, North Carolina law may require notice to customers and the Attorney General.

ON THIS PAGE

Quick answer: Disconnect infected computers first if ransomware hits your small business, then call your cyber insurer’s breach hotline before paying or hiring new vendors. Preserve evidence, report the attack to the FBI, and don’t pay a ransom without your insurer and an attorney. If personal information was taken, North Carolina law may require notice to customers and the Attorney General.

What we see at ALLCHOICE

The calls we get after a ransomware attack tend to start the same way. A business owner finds locked files and a ransom note, and the first question is whether to pay. By the time they reach us, someone has often already called an IT friend, started wiping computers or reached out to the attackers.

Our answer is the same each time: stop, don’t wipe anything, and call the breach hotline on your cyber policy first. Many cyber policies expect you to use their response team and approve costs before you spend money. And owners without cyber coverage usually learn that their general liability policy was never built for this kind of loss.

Not sure whether your business policy would respond to a ransomware attack? Your Risk Advisor can review what you have, or we can compare cyber coverage across top carriers.

Get a cyber insurance quote

What should you do in the first hours after a ransomware attack?

Contain the damage first, then get the right people involved in the right order. The steps below follow federal guidance from the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) and the FBI, with the insurance call placed where it protects your claim.

  1. Isolate infected systems. Unplug affected computers from the network and turn off Wi-Fi on them. CISA’s ransomware guidance says to power devices down only if you can’t disconnect them. Your regular IT team can help with this right away.
  2. Don’t wipe or rebuild anything yet. Wiping destroys the evidence investigators need to learn what was taken. CISA recommends taking system images and memory captures of affected devices.
  3. Call your cyber insurer’s breach hotline. Do this before you pay the attackers or hire a new forensic, recovery or legal vendor on your own. You can usually find the hotline number on your policy’s declarations page or in your carrier’s online portal. Many policies require prompt notice and approval of the vendors they pay for.
  4. Use the response team your policy provides. That often includes a breach attorney, forensic investigators and, when needed, a ransom negotiator. What’s available depends on your policy.
  5. Report the attack to the FBI. File a report with the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) and contact your local FBI field office. You can also report to CISA.
  6. Don’t pay a ransom on your own. Talk to your insurer, your attorney and law enforcement before any payment decision (more on why below).
  7. Find out what data was touched. If customer or employee personal information was accessed and taken, North Carolina’s breach-notice law may apply. Your breach attorney decides that.

Why call your cyber insurer before you hire outside vendors?

Because the order you do things in can affect what your policy pays. Many cyber policies set rules for who you hire, how fast you report and which costs need approval.

A breach hotline connects you to people who handle ransomware attacks every week. The FTC lists a 24/7 breach hotline as one of the features to ask about when you shop for cyber insurance. Your regular IT team can keep helping with containment while you make the call. But if you hire your own forensic or recovery firm first, part of that bill may not be covered, depending on your policy.

No cyber policy? Call your Risk Advisor anyway. We can help you check whether any other policy you carry responds, and point you to the reporting steps above.

Should a small business pay the ransom?

Federal agencies say no, and paying carries real legal risk. The FBI does not support paying a ransom, and says payment does not guarantee you’ll get your data back.

The bigger issue for a business owner is sanctions. The U.S. Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) warned in its 2021 ransomware advisory that paying a sanctioned person or group can bring civil penalties on a strict liability basis. That means you can be penalized even if you didn’t know who was on the other end.

OFAC also says a prompt, complete report to law enforcement or CISA, plus ongoing cooperation, counts as a significant mitigating factor. The decision to pay is ultimately your business’s, but don’t make it without first talking to your insurer, a breach attorney and law enforcement.

Does general liability or a BOP cover a ransomware attack?

Usually not in any meaningful way. A general liability policy or business owners policy (BOP) is built for bodily injury and property damage, and many of them exclude or sharply limit data and cyber losses.

Cyber insurance fills that gap with two kinds of protection. According to the FTC:

  • First-party coverage may help pay your own costs, such as breach attorneys, forensic investigation, data recovery, customer notification, crisis communications, lost income from business interruption, and cyber extortion.
  • Third-party coverage may respond when others make claims against you, such as lawsuits from affected customers, settlements, and the cost of regulatory inquiries.

Some BOPs add a small data-breach endorsement, which helps but is often limited. What a cyber policy covers, including ransom payments, varies by carrier and policy, and waiting periods, sublimits, exclusions and other policy conditions can affect how much is available. Our guide to what cyber insurance covers goes deeper on the coverage parts.

What this means in North Carolina

North Carolina’s Identity Theft Protection Act sets breach-notice duties for any business that owns or licenses personal information of NC residents. Under N.C. Gen. Stat. 75-65:

  • Affected people must be notified “without unreasonable delay,” after time to find out the scope of the breach and restore the system.
  • The Attorney General’s Consumer Protection Division must also be notified whenever you notify affected people, at any size, with the nature of the breach, the number of people affected and the steps taken. The NC Department of Justice takes these reports through its security breach reporting form.
  • More than 1,000 people notified at one time means the nationwide consumer reporting agencies must be told too.
  • If you only hold the data for someone else, such as an IT provider, payroll company or accountant, you must tell the owner or licensee of that information immediately after discovering a breach.
  • Law enforcement can ask you in writing to delay notice if it would impede a criminal investigation.

Not every ransomware attack is a “security breach” under the law. G.S. 75-61 defines it as unauthorized access to and acquisition of unencrypted personal information (or encrypted information along with the key to unlock it), such as a name combined with a Social Security, driver’s license or financial account number, where misuse is likely or there’s a material risk of harm. Whether your attack meets that test is a legal question for your breach attorney, who can also check whether other rules, such as HIPAA, other states’ laws or your contracts, require notice too.

The rules are the same statewide, whether you run a contractor office in the Triad, a medical practice in Asheville or a shop in Wilmington.

Questions to ask your Risk Advisor

  • Do I have cyber coverage today, or only a data-breach endorsement on my BOP?
  • Does my policy include a 24/7 breach hotline and a pre-approved response team?
  • Does it cover cyber extortion, business interruption and attacks on my vendors’ systems?
  • Does it cover notice costs and regulatory inquiries under North Carolina’s breach law?

People also ask

Final verdict

A ransomware attack is decided in its first few hours. Isolate the damage, keep the evidence and make your cyber insurer’s hotline the first call, not the last. The time to find out whether your business has that hotline is before the ransom note shows up.

Compare cyber insurance quotes for your business

Already a client? Visit the Member Center or call 844.540.0463 to review your business coverage or report a claim.

Related: Cyber insurance in North Carolina · How do I get cyber liability insurance? · What should you do when an employee gets hurt at work in NC?

Sources

Coverage depends on your policy, carrier and situation. This article is general information, not a coverage decision — talk to your Risk Advisor about your policy.

NEW TO ALLCHOICE?
Get coverage from multiple carriers in one conversation.

We'll compare options for your situation.

ALREADY AN ALLCHOICE CLIENT?
Review, update, or bundle your coverage.

Tell your Risk Advisor about changes to your household.

Member Center