How an Independent Agency Works — 2026
How ALLCHOICE
Works for You
An independent insurance agent represents multiple insurance companies, not just one. At ALLCHOICE, that means we compare 20+ carriers on your behalf, show you real options side by side, recommend the best fit, and stay with you through every renewal and claim.
The short answer
What Does an Independent Insurance Agent Do?
An independent insurance agent is licensed with several insurance companies and works for you, not for any one of them. Instead of offering one carrier's price, an independent agent compares multiple carriers, explains the differences, and recommends the policy that best fits your needs and budget.
If your carrier raises rates or non-renews you later, your independent agent can move you to another company. You keep the same advisor and don't start from scratch.
Compare your options
Independent Agent vs. Captive Agent vs. Buying Direct
There are three ways to buy insurance in North Carolina. Here's how they compare:
| Independent agent (ALLCHOICE) | Captive agent | Direct / online | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carriers you can compare | 20+ carriers | One company | One company |
| Who the advisor works for | You | The carrier | No advisor. You decide alone |
| If your rate jumps or you're non-renewed | We re-shop and move you | Start over elsewhere | Start over elsewhere |
| Hard-to-place risks | Specialty & surplus markets available | Often declined | Often declined |
| Claims help | Local advocate through our office | Varies | Call center |
| Agency fees | None. We don't charge agency fees | No | No |
Our process
The ALLCHOICE Proposal Path: 6 Steps From Quote to Coverage
Every client, personal or business, follows the same six steps. It's how we make sure the recommendation fits your risk, not just your budget.
Claims come to us first. ALLCHOICE clients report claims through our office, not a carrier 1-800 number. Our Client Care team helps you document the loss, submits it to the carrier, and stays involved as your advocate until it's resolved. For many clients, that's the moment an independent agency proves its value.
After you buy
What Happens After Your Policy Starts?
Who we represent
The Carriers Behind Your Options
ALLCHOICE represents 20+ personal and commercial carriers, including Erie Insurance, Travelers, Nationwide, Progressive, National General, and Foremost, plus specialty markets for risks standard carriers won't write. No single carrier defines us. The right one depends on you. See all carrier partners →
FAQ
Common Questions About Independent Insurance Agents
People also ask
People Also Ask — Independent Insurance Agents in NC
Why do independent agents say they "shop" your insurance?
Because they can. An independent agent submits your information to several carriers and compares the offers side by side: price, coverage, deductibles, and claims reputation. A captive agent or direct carrier can only quote its own product.
Can an independent agent get me a better rate?
Often, but not always. The biggest advantage is choice. Different carriers price the same risk very differently, especially for older homes, coastal property, young drivers, or businesses. Comparing several carriers is the most reliable way to find the best value for your situation.
What does a Risk Advisor do at ALLCHOICE?
A Risk Advisor is ALLCHOICE's licensed insurance professional. Your Risk Advisor assesses your risks, compares carriers, presents multiple options, explains the tradeoffs in plain language, and helps you choose the right protection. Then they stay with you at renewals.
Is Erie Insurance sold only through independent agents?
Yes. Erie Insurance sells exclusively through independent agents, which is one reason ALLCHOICE represents it alongside carriers such as Travelers, Nationwide, Progressive, and others. We place each client with the carrier that best fits their needs.
Keep exploring